Members Only

Using Adobe Publish Online

Interactive publishing from InDesign to the web, made easy

Once upon a time, a creative pro/publisher had a dream. She dreamt she could take her beautifully-designed InDesign print document, perhaps add some interactivity—buttons, slide shows, or animations—then publish that document out to the world, so that anyone with a browser, on any device, anywhere, could view and experience the document. With Publish Online, this dream becomes reality. This “technology preview” feature, first available in InDesign CC 2015, allows you to publish your InDesign document to the web, including interactivity, while keeping your layout intact. Using Publish Online, your InDesign document generates a unique URL when it is published to Adobe servers. The Adobe website provides an interface for users to navigate your document, zoom in or out, share the document, download a PDF of the document, or even embed the document on another website (Figure 1). 20150210-pubon-1 To view this document online, click or tap here.

20150210-pubon-2

Figure 1: Publish Online documents can be viewed from any browser on any device. You can include interactive elements such as buttons and animations, as well as audio and video.

While it is a dream come true in many ways, there are currently several important limitations that mean Publish Online will not fulfill the wishes of every user. Perhaps the biggest single drawback is that the document is published on Adobe’s servers. This means that you cannot publish your document on your own servers, behind a firewall. And while the URL is unique and not easily discoverable, you cannot password protect the document. Finally, you cannot monetize the document; there’s no way to charge for it or

list it in an app or eBook store. But for many users and many types of documents, Publish Online offers a quick, easy, and low-cost/no-cost way to share your documents online. That most of InDesign’s interactive features, including animations, can be used is a big bonus. Contrast this with DPS, a solution that is expensive, requires significant resources, and doesn’t even support InDesign’s rich animation feature set!

Preparing Your Document

The good news about Publish Online is that no special preparation is required. Fonts in any format can be used, although it’s always a best practice these days to opt for OpenType or Typekit fonts when available. A Publish Online document is essentially like a fixed-layout EPUB that is published on Adobe servers. That means that your designed layout will remain intact. With CSS and HTML5 under the hood, you can use nearly all of InDesign’s interactive features in your document, too, and they will translate beautifully in the published document. You can include hyperlinks, buttons, object states (multi-state objects or MSOs), and animations, as well as audio and video files. The only exceptions are interactive features found in the Overlays panel—which are used primarily for DPS projects—as well as forms and bookmarks.

Setting the Options

Once you’re ready to publish your document, it’s as simple (literally!) as pushing a button. Click the Publish Online button in the upper right of your screen in the Application Bar (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Click the Publish Online button in the upper right corner to start the publishing process.

Figure 2: Click the Publish Online button in the upper right corner to start the publishing process.

You’ll also find a checkbox in the EPUB and PDF export dialog boxes that allow you to initiate the Publish Online process after your document is exported. Next, the Publish Online Options dialog box displays, and provides settings for determining exactly how your document will be published. There are only two groups of options: General and Advanced.

General Options

It’s important that you look through the General options (Figure 3) carefully.

General options let you update an existing document, set the title and description, a page range, and allow a PDF of the document to be downloaded.

Figure 3: General options let you update an existing document, set the title and description, a page range, and allow a PDF of the document to be downloaded.

First, you need to choose between Publish New Document or Update Existing Document. If you choose Update Existing Document, a drop-down menu appears, listing all the previous documents you have published, starting with the most recent (Figure 4). There’s an option to view them, in order to ensure you’re choosing the right document to update.
Figure 4: When you choose Update Existing Document, you’ll see a list of your previously published documents.

Figure 4: When you choose Update Existing Document, you’ll see a list of your previously published documents.

The ability to update existing documents was added in the CC 2015.2 update, and it is a welcome addition. Once you publish a URL for your document, you want to be able to maintain that URL even as you make corrections or other updates to the document. When publishing a document for the first time, fill in the Title information, which is the text that will appear at the top of the browser window when the document is viewed. You can also fill in Description information. This is what will be displayed when you share the document via Facebook, and is also displayed in the Web Dashboard, as discussed later in this article. You can choose a range of pages to export, using standard page syntax, such as 1,3-6,10. You can also use Export To to publish your document in pages or spreads. And while a Publish Online document cannot be downloaded directly, you can click “Allow viewers to download the document as PDF (Print)” which will enable your viewers to download a PDF of your document. Next, switching to the Advanced options, you can choose any of your Print PDF presets, including custom presets, and the PDF will be created with settings from the chosen preset. There are a few things to keep in mind when selecting this option. First, some of the interactive features may not be included in the PDF. You can create a custom Print PDF preset that includes hyperlinks, but no other interactive elements will be functional in the PDF, including buttons, objects states, or animations. Their appearance on the page may be correct, but they will not work. The other thing to keep in mind is that the PDF that is created can only be of your current document. This usually works fine, but sometimes including interactive effects, such as animations, will result in a document page that doesn’t work in a PDF. For example, let’s say you have a large object on the page that you want to fade in, and then fade out. On your document page, and in the PDF, you will only see the object as it appears in full size on the Fade In, which may obscure other objects on the page, and is not what you want your viewers to see. But for many documents, the ability to download a PDF makes it possible to view the document and its content offline. This can be an important criterion for many situations.

Advanced Options

Under Advanced Options (Figure 5), you can choose a cover thumbnail for your document. This can be the first page of the document, an inside page from the document, or it can be a separate image.

Figure 5: Advanced options let you choose a cover thumbnail, image export settings, and a PDF preset (if you are allowing readers to download a PDF of the document).

Figure 5: Advanced options let you choose a cover thumbnail, image export settings, and a PDF preset (if you are allowing readers to download a PDF of the document).

This cover thumbnail will be displayed in the Publish Preview dialog box when you’re uploading the file and will also display when you share your document on Facebook or in the Web Dashboard. If you select an external image file, which can be JPEG, PNG, or GIF, it’s best to use the same proportions as your document file, but the image will always be quite small, so a 72-dpi resolution is fine. Image Settings control the size and format of the images on your document pages. I recommend you leave the Format set to Automatic, which lets InDesign determine the best format for all your images. The default Resolution setting is 96 ppi, which will work well for most documents. However, if you want the highest image quality possible, choose 144 ppi. Note the warning that appears, however: HiDPI images will significantly increase page downloading times. If you choose to convert all images to JPEG, you can set the image quality to Low, Medium, High, or Maximum. If you convert all images to GIF, you can choose an Adaptive, Web, or System palette. The last option, Download PDF Settings, is available only if you have chosen “Allow viewers to download the document as PDF (Print)” under the General Options. With that option selected, this setting allows you to choose from any of your Print PDF presets, including any custom presets you’ve created (Figure 6).
Figure 6: If you check the General option to allow PDF downloads, you can use the Advanced option to choose one of your Print PDF presets.

Figure 6: If you check the General option to allow PDF downloads, you can use the Advanced option to choose one of your Print PDF presets.

Publishing the Document

Once you’ve set the General and Advanced options, you’re ready to click OK and publish your document. After you click OK, InDesign will take a moment to prepare the document; then the Publish Online dialog box will display (Figure 7) and show the progress of your document upload. My experience, and that of others, has been that the documents upload in a very reasonable amount of time.

Figure 7: Once your document has been uploaded, you can view or share your document, or copy the URL to the clipboard.

Figure 7: Once your document has been uploaded, you can view or share your document, or copy the URL to the clipboard.

Once the upload is complete, the dialog box shows the cover thumbnail, along with the title and description that you set in the General options. You can view the document, or click icons that allow you to share it on Facebook, Twitter, or via email. You can also copy the URL to your clipboard. You’ll always want to click View first to preview your document, and make sure it looks the way you want it to, especially if you’ve included interactive elements. The View option will open your browser and take you to the unique URL for the document, where you can click through each page to check it. When you return to your InDesign document, the dialog box is still displayed until you click the Close button.

Sharing the Document

If you want to share your document on Facebook, Twitter, or in an email, click the appropriate icon in the dialog box. Sharing on Facebook will open your browser and allow you to add a comment. The cover page thumbnail, set in the Advanced options, along with the document title and description you set in the General options, will be posted on Facebook (Figure 8).

Figure 8: Facebook posts include the document cover image, along with the title and description.

Figure 8: Facebook posts include the document cover image, along with the title and description.

When you share the document on Twitter, your browser window will open with a post that includes the document title and the URL. You can edit the entry and then post to Twitter. When sharing your document, be sure to use the hashtag #IDPubOn, so others can easily find your work. idpubonhashtag Sharing via email will open your default email application and create a new email with the document title as the subject, and the document description and URL in the body of the email. Click the Copy button to copy the URL to your clipboard. You can then post the URL in other social media or paste it into any other document.

Using the Web Dashboard

Once you’ve published one or more documents to Publish Online, it’s important to be able to manage these documents. InDesign provides the Web Dashboard management tool for this purpose. Choose File > Web Dashboard to launch the Dashboard in your default browser (Figure 9). 20150210-pubon-10a

Figure 9: The Web Dashboard Publications page (left) lists all your published documents, which you can view or delete. The Analytics page (right) shows combined statistics for all your published documents.

Figure 9: The Web Dashboard Publications page (left) lists all your published documents, which you can view or delete. The Analytics page (right) shows combined statistics for all your published documents.

The Dashboard opens to the Publications page, listing all the documents you’ve published, from the newest to the oldest, along with each document’s cover thumbnail, title, and description. The publication date for each is also listed. From this list, you can click on any document to go to the document URL. If you mouse over an entry, a Delete option appears that allows you to delete the document. Take care with deletions, though, since you can’t undo them, and make sure you don’t delete a document for which you have distributed the URL. The Analytics page gives you basic information about the behavior of the people reading your published documents. Overview shows cumulative stats for all your documents. Click Document Trends to see the number of Views and Readers for specific documents. Views shows the number of times any of your documents was viewed (visiting multiple pages within the same document counts as one view). If the same user refreshes the page in the same session, it is still counted as one view. The session ends after 30 minutes of inactivity, and from then on it is counted as a new view, which updates the view counter by +1. Readers shows the unique readers for your documents. When a document is viewed by the same browser on the same device, even if over several days, it counts as one unique reader. However, if the same reader opens the same document, but from a different browser on a different device, that will count as a new reader. Avg. Read Time (secs) shows the average amount of time spent viewing each document. In our example above, -almost six seconds were spent viewing per document—typical, perhaps, of today’s attention spans. Total Read Time (hrs) is the total time spent viewing all documents. You’ll usually view the Web Dashboard on your computer, having launched it from InDesign. However, you can also access the Dashboard from your phone or other mobile device (Figure 10), by logging in to https://indd.adobe.com/dashboard, and signing in with your Adobe ID. The pages are not responsive, but still, you can manage your documents when not at your computer. Figure 10: The Web Dashboard can be viewed from your phone or other mobile device. Figure 10: The Web Dashboard can be viewed from your phone or other mobile device.

Viewing a Document

Once your document is published, the real fun begins: viewing the document. Publish Online documents will open a window in your default browser, and icons will display at the bottom of the window. After a few seconds, the icons will be hidden, but they can be displayed again by mousing over the bottom of the window (Figure 11). 20150210-pubon-12a

Figure 11: Several functions are available via icons at the bottom of the Publish Online document screen.

Figure 11: Several functions are available via icons at the bottom of the Publish Online document screen.

When viewing on a computer, you can navigate from page to page using the left or right arrows adjacent to the sides of the document. Use the Toggle Thumbnails icon to view thumbnails, and click on a thumbnail to turn to that page. To zoom in, click the icon and click on the page; use the Zoom Out icon to zoom back out and view the entire document page. Clicking the Full Screen icon puts the document into full screen mode; press the ESC key to return to viewing the document in your browser window. The Share icon allows you to share the document on Facebook, Twitter, or via email. The options are the same as those available in the Publish Online dialog box when you publish the document (see “Sharing the document” above). The Embed icon generates code that can be used to embed the Publish Online document in a website page. See the next section, “Embedding a Publish Online Document in a Website,” on page <OV>. If, when publishing your document, you set it to “Allow viewers to download the document as PDF (Print),” the Download PDF icon will be available. When the icon is clicked, a PDF of the document will display in the reader’s browser window and can be viewed, saved, or printed from there. If you did not set the document to allow a PDF download, the icon will not be displayed.

Viewing on Mobile Devices

On mobile devices, such as an iPad, there are some additional ways to interact with a Publish Online document by using various gestures. In order to see the Publish Online interface, tap on the screen. As on a computer, navigation arrows are available on either side of the document page, or at the bottom of the screen, depending on the device. You can toggle  thumbnails and navigate by tapping on them. However, as you would expect on a mobile device, you can also swipe from page to page. Zoom in and out by pinching the page. Some functions, such as Full Screen mode, are not available on all mobile devices. This is often a limitation of the device. You cannot copy the embed code or download a PDF from mobile devices. Also, keep in mind that Publish Online pages are not responsive. That means, for example, that while most documents will look fabulous on an iPad, they may be too small to read easily on an iPhone without zooming in and out.

Embedding a Publish Online Document in a Website

While the ability to share Publish Online is useful, it’s not necessarily sufficient for engaging the target audience, especially if the document is related to a business or corporate enterprise. A document may need to be available directly from a website, and that’s where embedding a Publish Online document comes in. With embedding, you can display the document directly on a website page. To embed a document, it must first be published. Every published document has an embed icon, as shown in Figure 11. When you click the icon, the Embed On Your Site dialog box displays, showing a preview of your document as it will appear when it is embedded (Figure 12).

Figure 12: Embed options allow you to set the size and start page for the document as it will appear on your web page, along with the necessary embed code.

Figure 12: Embed options allow you to set the size and start page for the document as it will appear on your web page, along with the necessary embed code.

Embed options allow you to choose the size the document will be initially on your web page. You can choose a preset small, medium, or large size, or enter a custom value. The thumbnail displayed will change size to reflect the setting you’ve chosen. You can also set the document start page, using any page in the document, and that page will be the page displayed initially.  Usually, though, you’ll want to leave it set to page 1. The Embed Code field contains the code you’ll need to incorporate into your website. Click on the code to select it, and then copy and paste it into the appropriate HTML file on your site. The document will display in the size and with the start page specified (Figure 13).
Figure 13: Add the embed code to your website to make the document available directly from your web page.

Figure 13: Add the embed code to your website to make the document available directly from your web page.

You’ll notice in the document preview, and when the document is published on your website, there is a Read Now button in the center of the page. This provides a visual prompt to the reader that the page can be clicked. Visual prompts are important, but if you have other visual prompts on your web page, you may not want this button to appear. Fortunately, you can modify the code to remove it.

How to Remove the Read Now Button when Embedding Documents

When you embed a Publish Online document in a web page, a Read Now button displays over the first page of the document. You can remove this button by making a change to the URL of the document within the code before you add it to your website’s HTML. Here is an example of a standard embed code: <iframe style="border: 1px solid #777;" src="https://indd.adobe.com/embed/1dd285f0-92d2-494e-820a-d0eeb96c3312?startpage=1" width="650px" height="460px" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen="allowfullscreen"> </iframe> The URL of the document within this code (marked in red above) is: https://indd.adobe.com/embed/1dd285f0-92d2-494e-820a-d0eeb96c3312?startpage=1 Change the word embed to view and delete the start page information at the end of the URL. It will look like this within the embed code: https://indd.adobe.com/view/1dd285f0-92d2-494e-820a-d0eeb96c3312 This means your start page will always be page 1. But the document will other­wise function normally, and the Read Now button will not appear. When the embedded document is clicked on your website, it can be viewed within the frame in which it initially appears, using the navigation arrows. However, if the reader clicks anywhere on the page other than the navigation arrows, the document will change to full screen mode.

What’s It Good For?

So, who can use Publish Online, and for what kinds of documents? The answer yields a long list. Any type of document that doesn’t require password protection, or which isn’t directly for sale, is a candidate for Publish Online. If you think about it, one of the big problems today for digital distribution has to do with file format. If you have a document or publication—whether a book, catalog, or brochure—the challenge is how to make it available to the widest audience possible. Conversion to HTML for a website is not always a viable option, and PDF documents are limited, especially when it comes to engaging your audience with interactivity. Corporations want to extend the reach of their print collateral, and they can do so easily with Publish Online, while maintaining the look of their print products. Educational institutions have countless catalogs, brochures, and other information that they want to make available online. And almost every business that sells a product needs to find a cost-effective way to distribute sales and product information, often via both print and online. For these users and many others, Publish Online is an ideal solution. It offers the ability to create an online presence that’s finally “one-click,” and provides an opportunity to add rich media and interactivity, all while utilizing existing resources. It’s of no small significance that InDesign’s interactive features are accessible and relatively easy to learn for anyone who is familiar with InDesign, and no other application or coding skills are required. The possibilities are endless. You can see several examples of currently published documents on the previous pages: from magazine publishers, to universities, to manufacturers, Publish Online provides a great solution for making documents easily available anywhere.

Publish Online Examples (click to view)

Corporate Brochure Morisawa USA

This Japanese font vendor and Typekit partner converted their corporate print brochure to an interactive online version.

This Japanese font vendor and Typekit partner converted their corporate print brochure to an interactive online version.

Product Catalog Soul Electronics
This slick, interactive product catalog for headphones includes a music video by Korean Gangnam Style star Psy.

This slick, interactive product catalog for headphones includes a music video by Korean Gangnam Style star Psy.

Annual Report, Non-profit Trabajo y Persona
This Venezuelan non-profit created an interactive online version of their annual managment report.

This Venezuelan non-profit created an interactive online version of their annual managment report.

Product Catalog The Lighting Company
This UK-based company created a magazine-inspired catalog that includes product links back to their website.

This UK-based company created a magazine-inspired catalog that includes product links back to their website.

Photography Book Atlas Magazine
This Turkish publisher of a magazine that emphasizes photography embedded a photo essay book about Mt. Karaca on their website.

This Turkish publisher of a magazine that emphasizes photography embedded a photo essay book about Mt. Karaca on their website.

University/College Publication Brown University
College football season is brought to life in this highly interactive guide that includes all the stats, sights, and sounds of the game.

College football season is brought to life in this highly interactive guide that includes all the stats, sights, and sounds of the game.

Magazine BlagMAG
This glossy magazine, Skin, is embedded on the publisher’s website, so the entire site is the magazine, which is viewed full-screen.

This glossy magazine, Skin, is embedded on the publisher’s website, so the entire site is the magazine, which is viewed full-screen.

Symposium Program Thailand Creative & Design Center
The interactive program catalog for this organization’s annual symposium, “Creativities Unfold,” is linked to the event home page.

The interactive program catalog for this organization’s annual symposium, “Creativities Unfold,” is linked to the event home page.

Looking to the Future

Publish Online is a new technology, and very much in its infancy. And so there’s plenty of room to grow and improve. There are many features that need to be included in the future. Features we’d like to see down the road include:

  • Searchable text
  • Integration with InDesign’s Book panel
  • The ability to choose a separate PDF to be downloaded (for example, one that doesn’t have interactive elements that might otherwise obscure content)

Perhaps more importantly, we believe that in order for Publish Online to remain an evolving, robust technology, Adobe is going to have to figure out a way to allow users to password protect or otherwise limit access and sharing of Publish Online documents. For many companies—no matter what Adobe does with Publish Online on Adobe servers, even if they can, for example, add some kind of password protection—the technology is not an option unless Publish Online can be run on their own corporate servers. Much of the content of corporate America cannot and will not be placed on Adobe servers. It would be interesting to see if Publish Online could be made available as some kind of SDK (software developer kit), where a company could license technology from Adobe, but run it on their own servers. There is certainly precedent for this, WordPress being just one example. Time will tell. In the meantime, Publish Online remains a very exciting option for publishing all kinds of documents. With just the click of a button, InDesign content, including interactivity, can be made available online for users of all kinds of devices, anywhere, to view, engage in, and enjoy.

Bookmark
Please login to bookmark Close

Not a member yet?

Get unlimited access to articles and member-only resources with a CreativePro membership.

Become a Member

Comments (22)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Peter Ståhl
    April 24, 2017

    Is it possible to publish a book-file in any way? I can only see how to publish each document separately.

  2. Cory
    October 20, 2016

    I am new to the Publish Online/Interactive side to InDesign, so forgive my relative ignorance of the subject.

    Can the Publish Online feature be used for email marketing? That is, is it possible to design a document in InDesign, publish online, and use the embed code to create an HTML ready e-blast with usable links?

  3. Mark
    October 19, 2016

    • Any plans to allow users to host Publish Online files? Currently, docs can only be hosted on Adobe Servers. In other words, we can’t host on our website or internal intranet. Our IT dept. may have security concerns

    • Also, is it possible to publish a book (INDB) using Publish Online.

  4. Aaron
    September 23, 2016

    @Veronique: Salut, je pense que non. Voyez :
    https://forums.adobe.com/thread/2174826

  5. Véronique ROS-SAUTET
    September 23, 2016

    Bonsoir,
    Un article bien intéressant et des commentaires bien à propos.
    Je n’ai pas vu s’il était possible d’utiliser la fonction “Livre” d’InDesign avec Publish Online.
    Quelqu’un sait ?

  6. Paul
    June 27, 2016

    Are there any limits to the size or number of documents a user can publish?

    1. Michael Ninness
      June 27, 2016

      @Paul No, there is not a limit on the number of documents a user can publish. I don’t believe there is a file size limitation either, but that said, it may take substantially longer to publish if you are pushing a huge file.

      1. Paul
        June 27, 2016

        Thanks Michael! Found some other great info worth sharing here https://helpx.adobe.com/indesign/publish-online-faq.html

  7. May 2, 2016

    This article helped me so much with my project! thank you so much… although i had few people telling me that on Microsoft Surface the MSOs are not working any thoughts?

  8. Michael Ninness
    March 7, 2016

    @Annette — I am the source, as the Sr Director of Product Management for the Web and Graphic Design products at Adobe, including InDesign.

    1. March 7, 2016

      @Michael, that is very reassuring. Thank you!

  9. DesignGirl
    March 1, 2016

    HI – Is there a CC 2014 version available?

  10. February 26, 2016

    Would be great for publishing a sample of a book on author websites.

  11. February 26, 2016

    What happens to the Publish Online documents if a user lets his Adobe license lapse?

    1. Michael Ninness
      February 26, 2016

      The hosting of the published document is not tied to your active subscription — only the ability to create and publish the document is.

      1. Annette Murray
        June 28, 2016

        The Adobe FAQs have a different answer.

        What happens to my published documents if I cancel my membership?

        Your documents will continue to be hosted on Adobe servers for at least 90 days after your membership expires. Adobe may choose to stop hosting after the 90-day period.

      2. March 7, 2016

        Michael, Can you point me to your source for your answer that the published document is not tied to an active subscription?

  12. Bart Van de Wiele
    February 24, 2016

    This article is awesome! Very comprehensive, I’m gonna share this with clients.

    Thanks Diane!

  13. February 23, 2016

    Quote: “Also, keep in mind that Publish Online pages are not responsive. That means, for example, that while most documents will look fabulous on an iPad, they may be too small to read easily on an iPhone without zooming in and out.”

    That, in a nutshell, is precisely what’s wrong with digital publishing. It fails to accomplish what should be its most important objective: displaying well on all sizes of devices. Attention has been devoted everywhere but to what matters.

    First there was a silly madness about multi-media. Anyone who’s actually done publishing knows that 99% of the time, that’s a non-starter. It costs lots of money to do video poorly. It costs a Hollywood budget to do it well. Fiction or non-fiction, it doesn’t matter.

    Now it’s easy to see that Silly #1, multi-media, is being supplemented by Silly #2, interactivity. True, the cost curve for that is not nearly as awful. No expensive team, location, and actors are required. The same person doing layout can make it interactive.

    But for what purpose? I have laid out and published dozens of books for myself and others. I can think of only one, my Lord of the Rings chronology, Untangling Tolkien, that would benefit from an significant interactivity. Most books and magazines only need the modest interactivity already provided by a table of contents. Any more than that simply overwhelms users with choices they have no need to make. It turns what should be a clean and attractive screen into something cluttered and distracting.

    What is needed is precisely what that quote above describes. People read digital publications on a wide variety of screens from a smaller smartphone through tablets up to large desktop screens. One size fits all formats such as these make no more sense that making one size of shoes for everyone.

    What’s needed isn’t more multi-media or interactivity. What’s needed isn’t even new. It’s much like what Framemaker offered in print media in the late 1980s.

    With Framemaker, the flexibility came with added content. Add a new paragraph to a 1,000-page technical document, and the entire rest of the document would reflow, Dealing intelligently with illustrations and tables. That’s because an illustration wasn’t locked to a specific place on a specific page as with ID. The person who placed it specified where it was to go in a broader sense, i.e. at the top of the next column. Adding text merely shifted the page where it appeared not how it appeared. The basic layout remained the same. For tech writers, that saved a lot of time.

    Digital documents need to display similar intelligence with screen size changes. The person doing the layout shouldn’t be stuck with designing it for an iPad, knowing the result will look awful on an iPhone. The layout and the display software should be smart enough to adapt.

    For example, what’s two columns on an iPad, with the illustration at the top of the second column, not only becomes one column on an iPhone, it deals intelligently with that illustration. The person doing the layout can choose how that illustration displays on smaller screens. If it matters that readers see it, he can have it appear on the next screen on which it fits without triggering awkward screen breaks. If it doesn’t matter, he can have a placeholder icon that, when tapped on, displays that illustration full screen. Whatever the choice, the result looks professional.

    In much the same fashion, text needs more flexibility as to whether it is hidden or displayed. Currently, those laying out an ebook face three choices about supplemental information:

    1. Leave it out.

    2. Place it into the text.

    3. Use a clumsy and (in iBooks) ugly pop-up screen.

    Allowing a feature much like the accordion text of webpages would solve that problem in a far more elegant way.

    I could go on and on. What neither Adobe or anyone else is offering is a way for those doing digital publications to control how they appear. They’re faced with two choices, Both equally bad.

    1. One is crude, reflowable formats that give almost no control over appearance. Thus far, no on seems to have even made them smart enough to handle windows and orphans.

    2. The other is a fixed layout designed for only one specific screen size and unsuitable for any other.

    This is really crazy. The first reflowable formats started off right, breaking lines of text to fit onto a screen. But they stopped there rather than move on. Guided by whoever is doing the layout, they should be able to adapt, intelligently and attractively, to any size display. Webpages can already do that to a great extent. Why not other publications?

    Only when that can be done will genuine digital publishing be available.

    1. AaronA
      September 12, 2016

      Michael, thanks for your well-considered post. As far as responsive design, I picture something like the Liquid Layout rules used for alternate layouts. Except with more choice on the part of the user as to the re-layout priorities and strategies. Just as we can adjust Justification settings for text, with percent values and limits, etc. determining how it flows.

      Or is this sort of dynamic responsitivity currently doable through HTML5 and alternate style sheets? (In which case it seems like the logical upgrade to Adobe’s Publish Online feature/service.)

    2. February 23, 2016

      Michael, I appreciate you weighing in on this, but I think you’re missing several important points:

      • InDesign can already export documents in a format that is reflowable to different media sizes, called EPUB.
      • InDesign is not Framemaker, and probably never will be. You can create highly-structured documents in InDesign, but that’s not its core strength. (There are, however, many systems based around InDesign that do what you describe, such as Typefi.)
      • Just because you don’t care for interactivity or find it useful doesn’t mean that other people don’t like it. Your argument could be made for any design, including fonts. I have, in fact, heard people say that choosing any font beyond Courier is frivolous and unnecessary, because what really matters is the text. If interactivity doesn’t help your document, then don’t use it. But if an animation or pop-up (or drop cap or color or any other design element) helps the communication and the design, then by all means you should take advantage of it!
      1. becky.kurk@thomsonreuters.com
        March 3, 2016

        David, great response to MWP :-)