*** From the Archives ***

This article is from January 23, 2006, and is no longer current.

Photoshop, Industry Giant

Photoshop is far more than an application — it’s an entire industry. It dominates the image-editing world because it’s a worthy tool created by a team that responds to user input and can keep pace with rapid technology shifts.
But is it always the right choice? Is there room for other software? To tell me what you think. Cick on the Comments icon and add your comments.

  • anonymous says:

    I’m a engineer/techwriter, machine tool industry (mostly)
    Main image editor=Corel Photo Paint
    alternate editor: The Gimp.
    I have never (in 20 years of this, and occasional DTP)used Photoshop.

  • anonymous says:

    I have been using the beta of Adobe Lightroom and I’m hooked. I plan on getting the final version when available.

  • anonymous says:

    Photographer

    ACDSee is alternate viewer and editor, for the same reason Sports Illustrated uses it at the SUper Bowl, a very fast way to view and select/discard images. ALso OK for basic editing and batch processing.

  • anonymous says:

    iMaginator by Stone design, and even iPhoto by Apple. Apple has built in a lot of image editing tools into Tiger (CoreImage). Stone has a policy of free upgrades for life. Buy it now, own all future versions forever.

  • anonymous says:

    Pixmaker Pro,Photo Vista, 3d Photo Builder,
    All these support & supplant the Blending actions in Photoshop

  • anonymous says:

    Picture Window Pro

  • anonymous says:

    Besides Photoshop, I use Gimp (which is FREE and a decent Photoshop clone, minus Photoshop’s CMYK and Pantone support), Microsoft Paint, Adobe ImageReady, and a number of programs that allow for easy image format changes, such as Hijaak Pro, IrfanView, etc. Strangely enough, there are image formats that Photoshop does NOT support (such as making icons for Windows systems). Graphic Converter on the Mac is also useful.

  • anonymous says:

    Adobe Lightroom for initial editing
    iView Multimedia Pro for previewing and cataloging due to it’s incredible speed and ease of use

  • anonymous says:

    I still use Live Picture, although it runs only under OS 9. In many of its functions it is superior to Photoshop, and is able to do some things that Photoshop is incapable of. It is a program I use regularly in image compositing. I’d be lost without it, and only wish that someone would see the value of updating the code so that it will run under modern operating systems.

  • anonymous says:

    Fireworks

  • anonymous says:

    Corel Painter!
    I know I use it where I need the incredible tools to create things that would be difficult or impossible in Photoshop.

  • anonymous says:

    I use Xara Xtreme in combination with Photoshop to create images for my newsletters and web graphics.

  • anonymous says:

    I use Corel Painter a lot when editing images, yet it never gets included in these surveys. It has many tools, filters and brushes that are not available in Photoshop, and Version 9 is extremely compatible. The cloning function is particurly useful when combining images, and that one can paint on a layer with true subtlty is superior. Perhaps Paint Shop Pro does some of this, but I wouldn’t know.

    It would be interesting to do a survey on the use of this application.

  • anonymous says:

    Name your alternate image editor;
    Paint Shop Pro and Fireworks

  • anonymous says:

    I primarily use Photoshop but occassionally use Corel Painter

  • anonymous says:

    GIMP image editor, Inkscape, and Scribus.
    I do web, print, and graphics (T-shirts, etc.) using these three programs, on Linux.

  • anonymous says:

    I occasionally use ACDsee on XP for simple editing. I got it for cataloging media. I have started using GIMP on OSX rather than spend money on Photoshop. Neither is a replacement for Photoshop but I can get much of what I need done with them.

  • anonymous says:

    Corel Photo-paint

  • anonymous says:

    I use Corel Photo Paint X3

  • anonymous says:

    I also use Google’s Picasa for doing fast, simple, cleanup work on digital photos for a website. I can straighten, color and light balance, crop, and resize images into uniformity very quickly and for free.

  • anonymous says:

    (for mac) GraphicConverter

  • anonymous says:

    How about Adobe Lightroom

  • anonymous says:

    Corel PhotoPaint

  • anonymous says:

    I use Print Shop version 22 now for most of my photo corrections and greeting cards. Photoshop is also an option for me for detail of choosing a part of a photo.

  • anonymous says:

    I also use Photoshop Elements 4 for the “creativity” features and some of the other features that CS2 doesn’t have.

  • anonymous says:

    I use Photoshop mostly for print and Fireworks for web work. That is it. They more than serve my needs…

  • anonymous says:

    I pose the question only because of my own notion of what constitutes “editing”. In my opinion, if it doesn’t “move pixels”, it ain’t an editor! So applications such as Adobe Lightroom or Capture NX aren’t technically (in my mind) editors. You can’t swap heads or remove blemishes or eliminate trees and buildings with those applications. Raw processing software prepares images to be brought into editing software. Using that “logic”, Corel Photo Paint is an editor, while Capture NX is not.

    I can’t imaging giving up Photoshop.

  • anonymous says:

    I’m trialing Adobe Lightbox (beta) but I use both Photoshop CS2 and Photoshop Elements for my normal workflow, depending on the needs of the moment.

    Lee Eschen

  • anonymous says:

    For graphic web design Fireworks does it all for me. I almost never use PS, although I suppose I will have to actually buy it soon! ;-)

  • anonymous says:

    Bridge works smoothly and naturally with Photoshop CS2, I can put out quite a quantity with that combo

  • anonymous says:

    Debabelizer. Perhaps I can do similar things in Photoshop, but it has two stellar advantages – (1) easily handles batches with sophistication (like the 800 images just off my camera); and
    (2) great technical sophistication (like taking all pixels in a certain specified RGB range and doing something to them)

  • anonymous says:

    I use Adobe Lightroom beta since its first public version and I find it very useful. Of course, it is not intended to replace Photoshop, since its purpose is completely different. I will never stop using Photoshop, because there is nothing else like it.

  • anonymous says:

    As a testament to Photoshop, I would agree with the article, although Photoshop has its’ short comings which are being cancelled out with each new version.

    However, I use Fotostation, Canon’s ZoomBrowser and IfranView on occasion.

  • anonymous says:

    I often use GraphicConverter for quicker editing than PS – despite being seen as a format converter it actually has a very good sharpen filter and image enhancement tools for basic retouching, cropping etc. Excellent for saving files to virtually any format.

    I also used to use ColorIt! for excellent but simpler processing of images – this has now appeared in an OS X version but I have not been able to get it via download yet so it may be outdated if it lacks features, but I can’t confirm that – it does however claim to have layers, so certainly has some new features

  • anonymous says:

    I primarily use Macromedia Fireworks for Web dev jobs — and also just started using Google’s Picasa for quick image editing of most of my personal photos. It’s efficient and effective and free!

  • anonymous says:

    I use Photoshop about 50% of the time and I split the difference between Irfanview and Paint.NET – both have features or are easier to use than Photoshop for specific tasks.

  • anonymous says:

    Here is one important editing program that you overlooked in your article – CorelDraw Graphics Suite 12 which includes Corel PhotoPaint. It is a great suite that is comparable to Photoshop.

  • anonymous says:

    Macromedia Fireworks

  • anonymous says:

    Because our office uses CorelDraw 12 extensively, I’ll on occasion use Corel Photo-Paint 12. Photoshop is still my favourite application, but CorelDraw doesn’t allow me to quickly edit an image with PhotoShop when editing an image I have placed in my CorelDraw file. As soon as I figure this out I’ll probably never use Photo-Paint again.

  • anonymous says:

    Raw Shooter Pro (now owned by Adobe)

  • anonymous says:

    We run an entertainment website and usually convert or create our clients’ web banners. We also edit photos, create postcards, flyers, banners, t-shirt designs etc. using Fireworks. It has many of the same features as Photoshop, can use Photoshop plugins as well as those from Alien Skin et al and is much more userfriendly and in my opinion, intuitive than Photoshop. I took a class in Photoshop back in the day when we were still raw-coding HTML and learning Dreamweaver 2. We used Fireworks in my Dreamweaver class and compared to Photoshop, it was much easier and faster plus it integrates directly with Dreamweaver and Freehand and can export in a variety of formats – including Photoshop native files. I don’t know anything about the other programmes listed but you got my vote for Fireworks – at least as long as Adobe/Macromedia keeps this treasure around!

  • anonymous says:

    I am a photog working to make it my profession and use Photoshop for serious image adjustments. However, when I download file from my EOS 30D I often use the Utility supplied w/ the camera for initial adjustments. This is also satisfactory for images I just want to share w/ friends or send them to print. I plan to try Digital
    Photo Pro 2.1 w/ RAW files in the near future.

  • anonymous says:

    Painter
    Lightroom
    Live Picture

  • anonymous says:

    Lightroom, Digital Photo Professional

  • anonymous says:

    I use Corel PhotoPaint and Adobe/Macromedia Fireworks as well

  • anonymous says:

    Microsoft PhotoDraw 2000 – why they discontinued this program is beyond me – I use it as my primary graphics tool for everything.

  • anonymous says:

    Graphic Converter!

  • Corky says:

    In addition to Photoshop, I also use Corel PhotoPaint X3 and find it to be a very powerful program. Depending upon what I want to do with the photo, sometimes I use Adobe Photoshop Elements or PaintShop Pro.

  • anonymous says:

    https://www.dl-c.com/Temp/
    This program costs $100, is not as bloated as Photoshop and is great for photos… a lot of pros are starting to use it…

  • anonymous says:

    Corel Painter and Adobe LightRoom

  • anonymous says:

    Why Photoshop has become synanamous with Photo Retouching in India is because the people here have a tendency to blindly follow the safe path;as an Indian I can say this because I am a living proof of it.80% users here use Photshop as Image editing tool,instead of phot-retouching tool;whereas Corel Draw is perhaps used by 99% of users.There are very few who would try out a new,more innovative or a software with steep learning curve;and they are a community in themselsves.Why is Photshop always confused with DTP software is a funny thing;even though 50% of prepress printers don’t know the diffrence between “Bitmap Editing” and “Vector Image”;all they know is that files should be in 24 bit BMP format and CMYK profile.The most widely used functions of Photoshop in India is creating photo montage and adding/replacing of background.Though now designers who have broken out of the mould and set-up their own indi-studio are using Photoshop’s immense creativity.

  • anonymous says:

    Most Canon Users shooting in Raw Format need to use the Canon program for conversion then Photoshop. CS2 users can use Adobe Bridge to convert.

  • anonymous says:

    Fireworks
    Painter
    Gimp

  • anonymous says:

    As an alternative add-in software for Photoshop I often use Picasa as a quick way to see what I have in my digital photos. I’ll sometimes use the “I’m feeling lucky” button to see if there is potential in a photo, although it’s way too coarse of an adjustment for most photos. I use Picasa more just to do quick and dirty fast adjustments then I will open the same photos in Photoshop for fine tuning. I use Photoshop a LOT for digital paintings and collages.

  • >