Back

If your email is not recognized and you believe it should be, please contact us.

  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.Login

InDesign CS 5.5 bug related to combination of split columns and indented text?

Return to Member Forum

  • Author
    Posts
    • #62273
      Paul van Calster
      Participant

      Mac OS X 10.7.3

      InDesign CS 5.5

      I designed an illustrated book using the split columns feature all the time to switch from headings and one-column paragraphs to two columns, which works fine (except that it slows down ID appreciably, but that can be considered common knowledge).

      As I also needed projecting bullets in many of the paragraphs, I gave all paragraphs a left indent, which also works fine – most of the time. However, on some pages (less than 5%) ID seems to “forget” these indents in the first line of column – either on top of the page or below an image, and both in the middle of a paragraph and at the beginning of it.

      The text duly jumps back into place when I option-click the relevant paragraph style in the list, but the main problem is that the situation is not stable. After closing and reopening the file the problem can reoccur in either the same or a different place.

      Needless to say that this is very, very irritating. The workaround I came up with is effective but hardly less annoying. I use empty placeholder frames with text wrap to force the text in its ‘bed’. Not a great solution for a book of over a thousand pages in two languages. What is more, the instability means that the problem can occur in other places (and I don’t feel tempted to add some 5,000 to 6,000 placeholder frames throughout the book, if I can avoid it).

      This is clearly a bug (I also had it with ID CS5). The problem occurs in 11 (out of 12) files of the book, although it is more frequent in some of them. Other than the obvious fact that the issue is related to the use of the left indent (as a matter of fact, the problem doesn’t occur in the 12th file, where on account of a slightly different layout I didn’t use the indent), I have no clue what might be causing it.

      Anyone?

    • #62274
      David Blatner
      Keymaster

      That sounds very frustrating. Two questions: have you tried exporting the file to IDML and reopening it? That might get rid of any kind of corruption lurking inside the file. If the problem still occurs, would you be willing to share the document privately with folks at adobe so that they can figure out what's happening?

    • #62276
      Paul van Calster
      Participant

      Hi David, thanks for your response. No, I haven't tried exporting the file yet but will do tomorrow, and yes, I'm certainly willing to share the file with the Adobe people.

    • #62282
      Paul van Calster
      Participant

      In the meantime I saved the file as IDML and reopened it. I thought that took care of the problem because in one language layer (French) all the places with problems seemed okay. However, this was not the case in the other language layer (Italian). Moreover, the improvement was not stable, for after closing and reopening the file I was back were I had started. (I also tried to resave the file as IDML but caused additional problems.)

      Please let me know how I can send the file (and whatever is needed) to Adobe for further investigation.

      Many thanks for your help!

Viewing 3 reply threads
  • The forum ‘General InDesign Topics (CLOSED)’ is closed to new topics and replies.
Forum Ads