“Canva”—what an absolute joke!
Tagged: Race to the Bottom
January 28, 2019 at 11:34 am #113981
January 29, 2019 at 8:03 am #113996Dustin HMember
Canva has always had a digital design focus (although the founder came from the printed yearbook space), which has made their transition into print to be a flawed one for those of us that care about print quality. A majority of their users are oblivious to the issues with PDF quality as they just see an editor that’s free for them to use.
I do think it’s important for Canva to be very clear with the flaws in taking their designs to print. One simple way to identify a flaw in their print is to look at their color picker. Anyone that knows anything about colors will see the flaws in using hex codes on designs meant for print.
February 10, 2019 at 9:24 pm #114345Robert WhitneyParticipant
We’re starting to see more Canva files submitted for print also, we’re in the US. 99.9% of the files are, no shockingly, utter garbage but we run them anyway. Add bleeds where we can, stretch or squeeze the files to fit the expected final size, I’ve done horrific things to Canva files because I know there’s no talking sense to the people submitting them. On the upside, they’re oblivious what “good” means so they never notice!
February 11, 2019 at 10:41 am #114361Mike RankinKeymaster
Yikes, talk about not using the right tool for the job.
March 4, 2019 at 2:02 pm #114734David BlatnerKeymaster
Seems like this falls into the same category as people using Keynote or PowerPoint to lay out pages. Crazy, but it happens a lot.
April 10, 2019 at 5:10 am #114353Dustin HMember
We’re one of the rare online design companies that focused on print first (most started in social graphics). The biggest challenges for us were colors & bleed. Both for obvious reasons… Our solution to the color challenge was to create our own color picker vs doing what Canva and others did. What we wanted our color picker to do was display RGB colors that match up very well with a relevant CMYK color (we manually mapped them). This results in a less vibrant color selection than traditional online color pickers, but that’s because CMYK has less vibrant colors so you have to do that to get an accurate print representation.
The bleed challenges were very hard in the early years (we’ve been around since 2009). The hardest part was communicating what bleed was to someone who has never heard of it. So what we chose to do after several years of failing at that, was to not talk about bleed and instead build some functionality that would result in objects that were close to that bleed being automatically pulled out and into the bleed. Similarly, if something was at the midway point we’d push it back into the main canvas area. It’s worked really well for us. Every now and then we need to slightly reposition shapes, but it’s definitely the best solution we’ve come up with in the online design space.
Funny thing is that we’re a company of just 2 people (designer & developer), so when you look at what Canva has done with their company you can tell they’re mostly focused on creating content that generates traffic (They literally have over 3,000 pages talking about colors in case you don’t know what maroon is) and a little less on their editor.
Feel free to check out our editor to see the color picker we built and the bleed experience. https://www.mycreativeshop.com/
Good luck with those files ;)
June 14, 2019 at 7:36 am #117176Brett StoneParticipant
I recently ‘cleaned up’ a Canva image provided by a client for T-shirt design. I did this by using Illustrator’s Trace feature, and for this particular art it worked surprisingly well.
Insult to injury, however, is the printing company (TeeSprings.com, a popular provider for YouTubers and content providers) only accepts raster images for their production process. After multiple conversations with their support, they have no current way to accept vector files for production.Yet in their limited posts regarding production, it appears that THEY then vectorize the image for correct production.
June 14, 2019 at 11:53 pm #117189Jeremy HowardMember
I worked for several years at a printing press that ran some fairly old web presses and I haven’t seen anything produced by Canva that would cause problems for that older printing system. I have sent countless ads to press that contained rasterized text at 300 dpi without issue…
My suggestion would be that if the printing company that you use can’t print these kinds of files cleanly then find yourself a new printer!
March 8, 2022 at 11:19 pm #14360071wang houParticipant
And it’s clear that Canva isn’t geared towards print work. That’s why apps like InDesign exist. Canva is pretty much for web based stuff. It’s ideal for quick turnaround jobs that don’t require much detail.
As a professional designer and digital artist on the side, I have been using my xp-pen drawing pad with adobe photoshop, illustrator and InDesign for years, works great.
Canva is useful only for social media graphics. Basically it’s a graphic design tool for non graphic designers.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.