Back

If your email is not recognized and you believe it should be, please contact us.

  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.Login

Ownership of rejected designs

Tagged: ,

Return to Member Forum

  • Author
    Posts
    • #103908
      Patti Moran
      Member

      If this topic isn’t appropriate for this forum, please delete – I am not a member of any other group that might be able to answer this question, and since a good bulk of InDesign users are graphic designers, I thought this would be a good place to ask.

      One of my clients uses me as an ‘in-house’ designer (even though I’ve never set foot in his office) to design material for many of his own clients. I bill him, he bills them. This is all well and good.

      However, this evening, I discovered accidentally that he allowed his wife to use a logo I’d designed, which was not accepted by his client (they chose a different one I proposed), for her own website…without my knowledge or consent, and certainly without paying for it.

      I’m willing to let it pass this time, as it’s just his wife, and it’s just a dinky personal art site.

      But it raises the question… who owns rejected designs? Does your client have the right to do as he wishes with proposed designs that aren’t used… especially without paying extra for them? I always thought I might be able to sell rejected logos to other clients for a reduced cost, just to recoup my time on them.

      Is there an industry standard policy that covers this?

    • #103916

      Have a look on the resource page at Clients from Hell.

    • #103917
      Patti Moran
      Member

      Thanks! I will!

    • #103967
      Betty Taylor
      Member

      My contract specifically states that I own the copyright to any designs that are NOT approved for final production.

      I transfer copyright for approved designs, but not all designers do.

      The Graphic Artists Guild publishes a handbook that is a good guide for pricing and ownership questions. (I don’t always follow it exactly but it’s a good resource for information.) https://graphicartistsguild.org/handbook

      Even if you are letting it pass this time, you might send your client an invoice for use of the logo showing the price you would have charged, and then a line showing “payment waived.” Just so the client understands the value of the logo they are using, and the amount they will be charged if they do something like this again.

    • #103968
      Patti Moran
      Member

      Thank you, Betty! Those are good tips!

Viewing 4 reply threads
  • The forum ‘General InDesign Topics (CLOSED)’ is closed to new topics and replies.
Forum Ads